Back to Blog

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Which Affiliate Software Should You Choose?

Audrey Rampon
November 6, 2024
Updated:
November 21, 2024
Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Which Affiliate Software Should You Choose?

Are you considering Rewardful or FirstPromoter to manage your SaaS affiliate program? With business growth on the line, selecting the right affiliate management software is crucial.

Both platforms offer solutions to streamline your affiliate program. However, they have distinct approaches and features. In this comparison, we'll delve into their key differences, including features, pricing, and integration options, to help you make an informed decision.

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Overview

Let's start by understanding what Rewardful and FirstPromoter bring to the table.

What is Rewardful?

Rewardful is a dedicated affiliate management platform built specifically for SaaS and subscription-based businesses.

Whether you're running an AI software company, growing your fintech business, or expanding your health and wellness community empire, Rewardful is a great tool to run an affiliate program.

Thanks to its simplicity and efficiency, Rewardful lets you set up your affiliate program quickly.

For instance, integrating Rewardful with Stripe and Paddle Classic takes just three simple steps, with no code needed. Need to connect an email marketing platform to Rewardful? You’ll have plenty of options, from Mailchimp to Customer.io and more!

Additionally, Rewardful is known for its sleek interface—but don’t let the simplicity fool you.

Rewardful packs a punch with powerful features.

You can manage complex affiliate programs with ease thanks to advanced campaign segmentation, flexible commission structures, real-time reporting, and smart coupon code tracking.

Rewardful simplifies your affiliate management tasks, streamlining workflows to save you valuable time and fuel growth, all while minimizing administrative headaches.

What is FirstPromoter?

FirstPromoter positions itself as an affiliate and referral tracking platform for subscription businesses.

The platform offers features like a branded affiliate dashboard, one-click PayPal payouts, and two-sided rewards systems.

Their focus lies in providing tracking capabilities across multiple payment platforms and offering personalized referral links and coupon code tracking.

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: How Do They Compare?

Here's a comprehensive comparison of the two affiliate management software’s key features and capabilities:

Feature Rewardful FirstPromoter
Starting price $49 per month
(up to $7,500 per month from affiliates)
$49 per month
(up to $5,000 per month from affiliates
with a maximum of 1,000 affiliates)
Key features
  • Two-way Stripe sync
  • PayPal and Wise mass payouts
  • Customizable cookies and commissions
  • Self-referral fraud detection
  • Last touch attribution
  • Real-time analytics
  • Branded affiliate dashboard
  • Two-sided rewards
  • Basic tracking capabilities
  • Multi-platform integration
  • Subscription management for affiliate marketing
Integrations 30+ integrations Limited integrations with major platforms
Customer Support 24/7 live chat, email, video chat Email support and chat
Free Trial 14 days 14 days

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Key Features

Let's examine the specific features that set Rewardful and FirstPromoter apart.

Rewardful's Features

Campaign Management and Segmentation

  • Create targeted affiliate groups based on performance, location, or other criteria for optimal program management
  • Implement flexible commission structures for different campaigns to incentivize top performers
  • Set up private, invite-only campaigns for VIP affiliates or specific marketing initiatives
  • Customize terms and conditions for different affiliate types, ensuring clear expectations

Related: Discover the standard affiliate commission rates in your industry in this guide.

Advanced Affiliate Management

  • Design custom commission structures and cookie durations aligned with your business model
  • Streamline onboarding with bulk affiliate import capabilities
  • Protect your program with sophisticated fraud detection that automatically identifies suspicious activities
  • Create a professional, branded affiliate portal that reflects your company identity
  • Handle refunds automatically with smart commission adjustments

Robust Affiliate Payment Processing

  • Leverage seamless two-way Stripe sync for accurate tracking and calculations
  • Process up to 5,000 affiliate payments with a single click
  • Automate commission calculations, including variables like refunds and recurring payments
  • Monitor all transactions in real time through a comprehensive dashboard

Performance Analytics and Reporting

  • Track conversion patterns across different campaigns and affiliate segments to optimize your strategy
  • Generate customized reports with detailed breakdowns of program performance
  • Monitor key performance indicators through an intuitive dashboard

Dive deeper into Rewardful’s affiliate management features.

FirstPromoter's Features

Subscription Management

  • Track both recurring and one-time charges automatically
  • Automatically adjust commissions when refunds or chargebacks occur
  • Monitor the status of referred users across different stages

Standard Affiliate Management

  • Standard affiliate dashboard with basic branding options
  • One-click PayPal payment processing for affiliates 
  • Two-sided reward system for referrals
  • Basic tracking capabilities for links and conversions

Affiliate Payment Processing

  • Integration with multiple payment platforms, including Stripe, Paddle, and Chargebee
  • Basic commission structure management
  • Standard payout processing capabilities

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Integration Capabilities

Rewardful Integrations

Rewardful's extensive integration ecosystem sets it apart with thoughtfully chosen connections that matter most to SaaS businesses:

Payment Platforms

  • Seamless Stripe integration ensures accurate revenue tracking and automatic commission calculations
  • Paddle Classic integration supports global software sales and licensing management
  • Built-in support for regular bank transfers and multiple currencies, giving your affiliates flexibility in how they receive compensation
  • Automatic syncing ensures all transactions are properly tracked and attributed

Membership Platforms

  • LaunchPass integration helps manage subscription-based communities effortlessly
  • MemberStack connection enables smooth member management and access control
  • MemberSpace integration supports content gating and membership features

Marketing Tools

  • Mailchimp integration enables automated affiliate communication and engagement
  • ConvertKit connection streamlines email marketing campaigns and affiliate updates
  • Customer.io integration supports sophisticated marketing automation sequences

Automation and Customization

  • Zapier integration via Webhooks enables custom workflow automation
  • Flexible APIs to connect with thousands of other apps to extend functionality
  • Create custom workflows that match your specific business processes

Learn more about Rewardful integration options.

FirstPromoter Integrations

FirstPromoter offers integration with:

  • Standard payment processors (Stripe, Paddle and Chargebee, Recurly and Braintree)
  • Other integrations include Webhooks, Zapier, Make, and Albato 

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Customer Reviews

Rewardful Reviews

Rewardful consistently receives stellar marks from users, scoring 5/5 on Capterra. Many users give extra praise for our:

  • Intuitive setup process
  • Responsive customer support
  • Reliable tracking capabilities
  • Flexible commission structures

As one Rewardful customer puts it:

''Getting started with Rewardful is very straightforward, the implementation was very easy for us and the entire process is transparent. We run a SaaS business, and it seems like Rewardful was designed with recurring subscriptions in mind.
I've worked with other products and their affiliate programs before, and none have been as straightforward as Rewardful. The Stripe integration was the difference maker for us because it lets us see affiliate referrals and other metadata directly in Stripe as well as in Rewardful. We haven't needed this yet, thankfully, but it would help us identify fraudulent affiliates much faster, which was a huge headache for me when working with previous affiliate software.''

FirstPromoter Reviews

FirstPromoter users appreciate the tools:

  • Tracking functionality
  • Affiliate management features
  • Simple dashboard interface

That said, the most recent review of FirstPromoter mentions that users would like to see some more customization options:

''Although I like many things about FirstPromoter, there is one area that could be improved. I wish there were more options to customize the appearance of affiliate program pages to match your brand better.''

Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Pricing Comparison

Pricing Tier Rewardful FirstPromoter
Low-tier Plan $49 per month
For up to $7,500 monthly affiliate revenue
$49 per month
For up to $5,000 monthly affiliate revenue
Mid-tier Plan $99 per month
For up to $15,000 monthly affiliate revenue
$99 per month
For up to $15,000 monthly affiliate revenue
High-tier Plan $149+ per month
For over $15,000 monthly affiliate revenue
$149+ per month
For over $30,000 monthly affiliate revenue
Free Trial 14 days 14 days

See the details of Rewardful pricings and features in each plan.

5 Reasons Why Rewardful is the Best FirstPromoter Alternative

Deciding between Rewardful and FirstPromoter can be a tough choice, especially when their pricing plans are similar.

However, when you delve deeper into the features, integration options, and track record, Rewardful emerges as the clear winner.

Let's explore the key reasons why:

1. Extensive integration options

Rewardful seamlessly integrates with a wide range of tools and platforms, empowering you to streamline your affiliate program.

2. Accurate tracking and attribution

Benefit from precise tracking of traffic, sales, and other crucial metrics to optimize your affiliate marketing efforts.

3. Robust fraud protection

Safeguard your affiliate program with Rewardful's advanced self-referral fraud protection measures.

4. Dedicated support

Rely on Rewardful's dedicated customer success team to assist you with any questions or challenges.

5. Proven track record

Benefit from the positive experiences of countless satisfied users who have trusted Rewardful to power their affiliate programs. These include Clay, OpusClip, Taplio, and beehiiv. See their success stories and testimonials in these case studies.

Ready to Transform Your Affiliate Program With Rewardful?

While both Rewardful and FirstPromoter serve the SaaS affiliate management space, Rewardful's combination of powerful features, extensive integrations, and superior support make it the stronger choice for businesses serious about scaling their affiliate programs.

Experience the difference yourself. Set up your program in minutes and see why the best SaaS businesses trust Rewardful to power their affiliate marketing efforts. Sign up here.

FAQs - Rewardful and FirstPromoter Comparison

1. Rewardful vs. FirstPromoter: Which Affiliate Software is Right for You?

If you're seeking a cost-effective SaaS affiliate software with a proven track record, Rewardful is an excellent choice. It's designed to be easy to set up, providing a smooth onboarding experience for your affiliates. With over 30 integrations, including Stripe, you can seamlessly integrate Rewardful into your existing tech stack. And all of this starts at just $49 per month. Learn more about Rewardful features.

2. How Does Rewardful Pricing Compare to FirstPromoter?

While both platforms start at $49 per month, Rewardful offers a higher revenue limit ($7,500 monthly affiliate revenue) than FirstPromoter's $5,000 limit at the same price point. Check out the Rewardful pricing page for a detailed breakdown of features at each tier.

3. Can I Track Stripe Affiliate Transactions on Rewardful and FirstPromoter?

Yes, both platforms offer Stripe integration for tracking affiliate sales. With Rewardful's two-way Stripe sync, you get access to comprehensive tracking capabilities. The integration process takes only three simple steps—no coding is required.

Learn more about Rewardful's Stripe integration to see how it can streamline your affiliate program management.

Share on social media: 

Turn your biggest fans
into your best marketers.

Rewardful is a simple way for companies to setup affiliate and referral programs with Stripe. Just connect your account and let us track referrals, discounts and commissions for you!
Or learn more about Rewardful
"Transistor wouldn't be where it's at today if it wasn't for Rewardful"

Unlock your best new revenue channel today.

Get up and running in just a few minutes, with zero risk.
Try Rewardful free for 14-days
Used by many of the fastest growing companies in the world

More from the Blog

Affiliate Marketing

How to Manage Niche Affiliates in Health and Wellness

Looking to improve your niche affiliate program for health and wellness? Learn who your best affiliates are and how to manage the affiliate program effectively.

Affiliate Marketing

Affiliate Marketing Strategies to Grow Your Health and Wellness Brand

Discover some expert tips on how to grow a thriving health and wellness affiliate program. From recruitment to daily management, this affiliate guide has all.

Affiliate Marketing

The Best Affiliate Management Tools for Indie Hackers (Under $100)

Explore the best affiliate tools for indie hackers under $100. Boost your marketing with cost-effective, powerful software. Ideal for growing businesses.